What We Do


Cake Design

From weddings to birthdays, our cakes are the perfect (and delicious) finishing touch to your event! 



So many flavors it’s hard to choose! Have you tried our S’mores cupcakes? Let’s just say it takes the cake!



Our catch-all category covering a huge range of unique sweet treats, like dark chocolate covered cheese cake pops. (what?!) Let’s talk.



Whether traditional or adventurous, let’s just say these are not your grandmother’s pies!



Sometimes you just want a sugar cookie and sometimes you want a whiskey carmel apple cookie with cinnamon glaze. We can do both.



We don’t expect you to try to move that 4 tier dream wedding cake. So, let’s chat about options.

We want you to know how much we loved your delicious wedding cake and the great service you gave us for our July 28 wedding at Cuvee. The cake was even more delicious than we remembered and we got so many compliments on it, especially for the wonderful citrus cream cheese filling and buttercream frosting! You did an amazing job decorating the cake! It looked so beautiful – exactly what I had pictured!  You did such a great job!

-Amanda & Nick Cose

I want to thank you again for providing the samples for our two wedding cake choices. Kelly and I tasted both last night and talked a bit about both of them. Both were very, very amazing.  The Lemon/Strawberry is exactly what we are looking for. To quote Kelly, “Nobody is going to beat this.” There’s not much more to say!

-Mike Fink & Kelly Servais

Sweet Samples

new baby cake

sunshine cake

birthday cake

cake details

majestic cake

black & white cake

white cake

chili chocolate ganache

corset cake

lemon cake

black forest cake

lucky duck frosted cookies

black forest cupcakes

key lime cheesecake cupcakes


dessert table

our baker


The creative force behind Make Cake, Ashley started her love affair with all things sweet as a child. Always a stickler for details, she once mixed an entire bowl of brownies with her tiny little hands because the directions said “mix by hand.” Her passion has led her down to Chicago to attend culinary school at Kendall College then back again to Milwaukee to become one of the best bakers in town! In 2013, she placed 2nd in the Shepherd Express’ category of Best Wedding Cake Designer.

Follow Us